I have been worrying about slash fic, and more specifically, why I seem to have started writing it. Not worrying in an 'OMG, I'm gonna go to hell' way, it just puzzles me. I used to avoid it. I don't find the sight of two men kissing erotic. I'm vaguely squicked by the idea of two men having sex. I'm a girl, I don't have a prostate, my own experience of anal sex is pretty much 'that bleeding well hurts, I'm not doing it again without substantial sexual bribery' And that's still true. So why have I started writing fics where the whole point is to get two men into bed?
Because I'm weird, according to the person reading over my shoulder. (Hazard of borrowing people's internet. She didn't use the word weird, but she's definitely giving me funny looks now.) And it's fair comment. But I'm very far from alone. And if 'because they're weird' is the answer, how is it all these slash writers share the same weirdness? Every kink has its own little corner of the Internet, that's to be expected, how come slash is the one that's nearly taken over? I don't know if anyone has done a proper survey, but it seems to me, pretty much half of all shipper fic is slash. That's a lot of weirdos. It's very curious. I've been hanging around fandom too long to think it that strange, but it is. It's very strange. There's no Mills and Boon equivalent, out in the real world, few trashy gay romances written for women, but here in fandom - pretty much 50/50. And I'd like to know why.
( Please don't expect any kind of sensible answer to be under the cut. Just lots of rambling. )And I have one more reason, which only really occurred to me after far too much thinking about Ashes 2 Ashes. If Sam had been a girl in Life on Mars I'd probably have happily shipped it for a little while. I wanted a het ship. Now, in A2A, I'm being given exactly that, but I don't want it. Not just because Sam and Gene is now my OTP in that fandom. First up, I resent being told that they've added sexual tension to make the program more appealing to women. It makes me think murderous thoughts about Matthew Graham and if I end up liking A2A I'll feel bad about it. I resent being given what I want, I'm petty like that. But more germane to my slash puzzlings, I don't trust the writers not to screw it up.
I could watch Life on Mars, and ship Hunt/Tyler, secure in the knowledge that the writers couldn't ruin it for me. They could ruin the ending, but not the ship, because it's not and never would be a canon ship. And I think that applies to most slash pairings. Life on Mars was never going to show Sam and Gene getting romantic, so they couldn't show it badly. I was able to invest in that relationship, because of that. And it's not necessary a good/bad writing issue. Even if I'd managed to have the same kind of blind faith in the creators of LoM that I managed for Joss Whedon, I don't think I'd even want to see how that relationship might have played out on screen. If it's not a canon ship they can't show it reaching a conclusion. They were never going to take away my UST by making them a couple. And I can't think of
any heterosexual examples, where you could be
sure Male Character and Female Character weren't going to end up together and boring, except in closed canon. Maybe that's why I just can't get into Torchwood. There are no two characters, regardless of gender, generation or species, that might not jump into bed at any second.
so 11/
Because it's not a canon ship.
Eleven whole reasons. I'm not sure that's enough to explain why so many fandom members prefer slash. Or why they don't seem to apply to mainstream media. If anyone has a better answer, I'd like to hear it. And if anyone knows how it can be possible that I don't know myself why it is I do the things I do, I'd like to know that too. In fact, I think this is probably my longest ever non-fic post by a wide margin, I'd be quite impressed if anyone got this far. You can just consider this post one long advert for rough-drafting.